Mennonite Bishop’s Bold Stand In Sexual Abuse Case!

Finally, some good news to share! On the heels of The Elephant Grows Fat in Church, it is a thrill to share how a bishop in  Mennonite church, in Ontario, took an unusual and bold stand in a childhood sexual abuse case.

But, good news, in the case of childhood sexual abuse, is always bittersweet, because it comes at a price. Tragically the good news always hinges on the initial crime of victimizing a child. That, in and of itself, makes today’s post as tragic as it is exciting for me to write about.

When it comes to the topic of sexual abuse, I find the material heavy and somewhat depressing. I take a bit more emotional ‘down time’ just washing away the darkness that inevitably wishes to latch on to me, depressing me. I cry out to God a little more. I feel a bit more emotional. A bit more vulnerable. There seems little good to write about.

I admit, I feel badly exposing the dark side of my Mennonite heritage when there is so much good in it, but I fear if I remain silent, as many have, the good will be lost. So, depressing as it may seem, I press on….

But this post is different. It is a beacon in a dark and stormy night, giving hope to the many on the rough waters of victimization in the Mennonite culture.

To protect the identity of any victims, I will not use real names, and will not disclose the ‘brand’ of Mennonites, other than to say they are very conservative. That fact gives me hope that more will follow suit.

The perpetrator, Dan, is a friend of mine from the past, whom I met when I lived in Fresno, California, in the summer of 1987.

Dan was a ‘nice’ guy, and respectful. He had Mennonite background but didn’t ‘buy in’ until he was in his twenties. And that was twenty years ago. Over the years he stayed single, a member in good standing in the church. From time to time, when mom had talked to him, she would pass on his greetings, saying he would love to see me again, and meet my family.

Recently Dan’s bishop discovered that during his twenty years in the church, he has been sexually abusing young boys. What makes the bishop’s response unique, and a noteworthy detail, is that Dan is related to him, quite closely, through marriage. What’s more, Dan’s family is ‘highly respected’ as the ‘elite’ in the church, which alone gives cause for cover up at times, because the potential damage to church reputation.

To his credit, Dan’s bishop talked with Dan and told him he needs to turn himself in to the local authorities and offered to drive him. I am sick and saddened by the discovery that Dan violated young boys all these years. My heart breaks for the victims, some of whom are now adult men, no doubt struggling to make sense of their journey.

And my heart aches for Dan, for making choices that brought so much destruction. I know a bit of Dan’s story. His father was a rather vile man whose example was about as destructive as they get. His older brother raped my best friend in California while I was there.  Who was there for him? Who showed him the way? What was his story? Did he first suffer at the hands of another perpetrator?

Unanswered questions. None of which, if answered, would make the wrongs right. They could only shed light on the journey, but could do nothing to bring any sense of justice to the victims.

Above all, I am proud of the bishop for taking the hard road within the culture. I know him, though not well, having had occasion to speak with him a few times. It encourages me to see men of integrity within a culture of silence, men who are willing to take a stand. I never want to overlook honouring them and acknowledging the good they do.

Whether it will be the new norm, I don’t know. Whether this means that victims will be acknowledged and helped, emotionally and spiritually, without any guilt and shame placed on them, I don’t know. I pray so. I pray this is a new standard being set, for the purpose of hope and healing through Jesus, not any other reason.  Not to judge, punish or condemn. But to bring redemption, through JESUS, to the mess stuff of humanity.

Jesus came to give life, hope and freedom,  and truth is the channel through which these flow. Often we, humans, are called to guide that truth, to carry it, ad to ensure it is protected and revealed. Thank God for those who do it honourably.

© Trudy Metzger

Return to 1st post in Sexual Abuse Series

7 thoughts on “Mennonite Bishop’s Bold Stand In Sexual Abuse Case!

  1. Revelations in Writing July 23, 2012 / 11:40 pm

    I am so glad to hear that the silence is being broken so that the injured may have the opportunity to heal without hiding. Thank you for so bravely sharing your story, and for recognizing the redemption even in the darkest of scenarios. Praying for God’s grace for all affected by such abuse…

    • Trudy Metzger July 23, 2012 / 11:56 pm

      Yes… Praying for grace and thanking God for this unusual stand–a leader doing the right thing.

    • Trudy Metzger July 24, 2012 / 8:57 am

      Thank you for reblogging, Dale. 🙂

  2. Morven R. Baker July 24, 2012 / 6:51 am

    Sick at heart to read this, as so many people’s lives have been impacted by the actions of one “vile” father. I know we are responsible for how we respond to past abuse, but my heart aches for the little boys who were raised in his home and, knowing that sexual abuse is not about sex but about power, can almost understand why this man’s sons acted out. They were probably both molested as well.

    Praying for this broken body of believers, and especially for the little boys who were victimized. For the pastor … and for you, as you are a light in the darkness. I am praying that the Lord’s truth, mercy and grace will shine within you as you minister to your friends.

  3. Regina July 27, 2012 / 10:40 pm

    I rejoice to hear when leaders are willing to stand up for what is right even if no one else does. Breaking the silence is breaking the power . thanks , Trudy for persevering and being vulnerable in the goal of helping others to know there is freedom on the other side.

    • Trudy Metzger July 27, 2012 / 10:42 pm

      Thank you Regina. Yes, there is freedom on the other side and each time I see it, or get to play a hand in that process, it gives me the courage to keep going. I wouldn’t trade that thrill for the security of silence and privacy!

Comments are closed.